← All stories

Part of Silver Rail shooting aftermath continues in Bend as gun debate and recovery grants unfold

Silver Rail father is first recorded civilian to shoot and stop a school attacker

PreviouslyNov 20 — Concealed carry applications triple in Deschutes County after Bend school shooting

No. 13·296 words·1 min

Kaylub Giamanco, the Bend father who followed the Silver Rail Elementary shooter into the school on Oct. 15 and killed him, is the first recorded case of a private citizen shooting and stopping a school attacker, according to The Violence Prevention Project, which has tracked nearly 400 school shootings since 2000.

The shooter, a Bend teenager, killed four people inside the school before Giamanco shot him.

The rarity of the case has not settled the argument it sits inside. Some read Oct. 15 as evidence that a gun killed students and teachers; others as evidence that a man with a gun stopped a killing. Both readings have organizations behind them.

Matt Osborne, a former CIA officer and a certified instructor for the United States Concealed Carry Association, said armed civilians are "the last line of defense if other things fail — such as security measures at the school or law enforcement." The group teaches its members that they are responsible for every round their firearm fires, he said, including any that strikes an innocent person.

Amie Wexler, executive director of Alliance for a Safe Oregon, said the intervention is not the measure that matters. "What we know that really works is stopping a firearm before it reaches the door of the school, and if a firearm has already reached the door of the school, we've failed," she said. She believes the solution is more access to safe storage, use of Extreme Risk Protection Orders where warranted, and keeping firearms away from young or dangerous people.

Deschutes County is among the Oregon counties that use those orders most, according to the Oregon Health & Science University Gun Violence Prevention Research Center: from 2018 to 2024, 34 or more orders for every 100,000 residents, above the state average.

Discuss on the board