← Today’s paper

From the paper of Wednesday, October 7, 2026

Military judge suppresses al-Hawsawi's statements in the 9/11 case

No. 16·555 words·2 min

A military judge has ruled that Mustafa al-Hawsawi's confessions to FBI agents at Guantanamo Bay cannot be used against him, making him the third defendant in the long-running 9/11 case to have his statements thrown out.

Col. Michael Schrama's 51-page decision, dated Oct. 2, was not immediately released by the Pentagon; portions were marked as Controlled Unclassified Information, subject to review by a security officer and possible redaction. In the unclassified passages, the judge rested the suppression on a decision by the George W. Bush administration not to have federal agents give al-Hawsawi a Miranda-style warning when they questioned him across four days in January 2007.

"Crucially, the FBI agents deliberately chose not to give Miranda warnings or any equivalent rights advisement," Schrama wrote. "Furthermore, they failed to provide a cleansing warning informing Mr. Hawsawi that the statements he had previously made under coercion to the CIA could not be used against him."

By then al-Hawsawi, a Saudi citizen accused of arranging money and travel for the hijackers, had been held nearly four years, mostly in CIA custody. He was held in six CIA prisons overseas, starting with one in Afghanistan known as Cobalt, where the judge's narrative describes him being interrogated naked or in a diaper, kept awake 24 hours and then questioned for 14 more, and subjected to water-dousing, slapping, walling and cramped confinement. A CIA interrogator said the unapproved water dousing had the same near-drowning effect as waterboarding, Schrama wrote. A body cavity search in November 2003 left him bleeding.

Schrama did not rest the ruling on torture. He found the 2007 interviews failed the legal test of attenuation — that a confession be untainted by earlier coercion. Prosecutors argued the change in time, place and questioner met that standard. The judge found the claim less credible because agents questioned al-Hawsawi at Camp Echo II, the same compound of small huts where the CIA had held him from November 2003 to April 2004.

"A detainee who is shackled, transported to a former CIA black site, and intentionally kept ignorant of both his right to remain silent and the inadmissibility of his prior coerced confessions, cannot be said to be making an 'essentially free and unconstrained choice,'" he wrote.

To a person subjected to years of operant conditioning — the term used by the CIA's own consulting psychologists — a simple assertion of a "blank slate" by agents of the same government could not sever the effect of the earlier abuse, the judge wrote.

Bush officials also chose not to record the new interviews. The agents instead wrote narrative accounts of the admissions, which the defendants never signed and saw only later, in pretrial discovery.

It is the fourth time a military judge has rejected the Justice and Defense Departments' effort to obtain fresh confessions from former CIA prisoners. Schrama suppressed Khalid Shaikh Mohammed's 2007 statements last month; prosecutors declined to appeal, to protect a June 2028 trial date. They appealed Ammar al-Baluchi's suppression, and that appeal is pending. Schrama has yet to rule on a challenge by Walid bin Attash.

Without the clean-team testimony, prosecutors will likely have to build their case on financial documents, wiretap transcripts and other statements attributed to some defendants. The case began with five defendants and now has four; one was ruled mentally unfit to stand trial.

Discuss on the board