← All stories

Senate passes energy permitting overhaul, 62-33, sending it to the House

PreviouslyNov 20 — Senate advances permitting bill that would end tribal consultation on sacred sites

No. 12·549 words·2 min

The Senate passed the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act on Thursday, 62-33, moving a sweeping rewrite of federal energy permitting to the House with few days left in the lame-duck session. It is Congress's first major action since the midterm elections.

The bill would shorten environmental review times and narrow the criteria that trigger full reviews under the National Environmental Policy Act, require data centers to pay for the electricity and grid capacity they use, and remove the obligation to consult tribes on certain projects under Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act.

Fifteen Democrats voted for it, including Minority Leader Chuck Schumer. Two Republicans voted against: Josh Hawley of Missouri and Mike Rounds of South Dakota. President Donald Trump urged approval, calling it a "BIG WIN for U.S. ENERGY INDEPENDENCE and DOMINANCE" in a social media post.

Sen. Martin Heinrich of New Mexico, one of the four senators who negotiated the bill, said it would "strengthen Tribal consultation." Tribal advocates and California Democrats say it does the opposite. Sen. Adam Schiff sponsored an amendment to strike the historic preservation changes; 36 senators joined him and it failed. Sen. Alex Padilla said the bill "threatens Tribal sovereignty" and could allow the destruction of ancestral lands and sacred places "without adequate legal recourse for the communities that have relied on them for generations."

Oneida Nation Vice Chairman Jameson Wilson said the bill threatens the tribe's ability to protect its sacred spaces, ancestors and ceremonies. Wizipan Garriot, president of the NDN Collective, said the fight moves to the House, which "still has the chance to do the right thing."

Environmental organizations are split. The Environmental Integrity Project, the Sierra Club and the National Wildlife Federation oppose the bill, citing limits on judicial review and changes to the Clean Water Act and Endangered Species Act. Jen Duggan of the Environmental Integrity Project called it "a backroom deal" that would "pave the way for even more fossil fuel projects like gas power plants for data centers, oil and gas pipelines and LNG terminals." Aaron Weiss of the Center for Western Priorities said senators "who promised Westerners they would stand up for our public lands just voted for a bill that sells them out to Big Oil and Big Tech."

Industry groups representing clean energy and oil and gas developers support the bill, saying it would deliver more electricity to the grid and cut delays that can stretch a decade or more. Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island, another negotiator, called it "the floor, not the ceiling, of our climate and environmental aspirations."

Sen. Jeff Merkley of Oregon said getting more renewable power where it is needed "doesn't tackle climate change if you simultaneously promote the burning of more fossil fuels." He and Sen. Ron Wyden pushed amendments, including a ban on data centers on public lands; Republicans blocked votes on them, and the bill passed without any rank-and-file amendments.

In the House, Natural Resources Committee Chairman Bruce Westerman said the vote was "a strong step forward" and that he looks forward to passing the bill swiftly. The House approved a more limited, industry-friendly version last year. Weiss urged the House to reject this one and let the next Congress write a bill that "builds clean energy without sacrificing America's public lands."

Discuss on the board